Twice she won a jury trial against an insurance provider who denied a claim after her husband died of COVID-19. But Vaneza Ramos, a widowed mother of 10, has yet to see any of the roughly $12 million awarded.
Farmers New World Life Insurance has not answered Ramos’ request to pay even a portion for now, namely the $350,000 value of the original policy, said her attorney. Instead Farmers has asked for another trial, or that a judge reduce the award amount.
On Monday, Ramos’ legal team turned to the Nebraska Department of Insurance for action.
In a regulatory complaint to Insurance Director Eric Dunning, attorney Ross Pesek of Pesek Law asked that the agency investigate what he alleged could be a systematic “bad faith” practice by Farmers. He wants the state to find out whether other Nebraska families have been denied benefits through similar Farmers procedures and if laws were violated.
Pesek described the alleged practice as selling life insurance policies without obtaining available medical records, collecting premiums and, after a death, obtaining medical records to retroactively justify denying a claim.
Ramos’ husband, Jose Gaytan, died within a two-year timeframe when a claim can be contested. Farmers denied the $350,000 life insurance claim that named Ramos as beneficiary, saying Gaytan had a history of a heart attack and that a post-death investigation showed he failed to disclose the medical condition on his application.
The company instead tried to send Ramos a $17,360 check, the amount Gaytan had paid into the policy. Two different Douglas County juries later sided with Ramos, one awarding the policy amount plus attorney and court costs, and the second calling upon Farmers to pay $11.3 million for bad-faith damages, bringing the total judgment to roughly $12 million.
Pesek said in his Monday complaint that the Nebraska Supreme Court has interpreted state law to require an insurer seeking cancellation of a policy based on misrepresentation to prove the policyholder made the incorrect statement knowingly and with intent to deceive.
He cited testimony from the Ramos trial and a separate Nebraska appellate case involving Farmers to support his request for a deeper look.
“Only an examination of Farmers’ actual claim files can establish the scope of this problem,” he wrote.
Martin Swanson, deputy director of the Nebraska Department of Insurance, said Monday the department does not comment on investigatory matters.
Farmers’ lawyers did not respond to requests for comment.
Farmers, however, did file a motion in Douglas County District Court late last month seeking a new trial or for a reduction in the Ramos award amount. The company argues that financial damages presented during trial totaled less than $200,000.
In challenging the bad-faith amount, Farmers attorneys argued that it was excessive and appeared to be punitive damages — which they said are not allowed under Nebraska law.
“If an award of damages shocks the conscience, it necessarily follows that the award was the result of passion, prejudice, mistake, or some other means not apparent in the record,” the insurer said in a court filing.
The jury verdicts came from two separate Douglas County panels: In March, one jury found that Farmers breached its contract when it declined to pay the life insurance policy on Gaytan. Last month, the second jury found that Farmers acted in “bad faith” and awarded the $11.3 million.
Pesek said the family’s recent request that Farmers at least pay the original policy amount has gone unanswered.
The two verdicts came six years after Gaytan’s death in 2020 of COVID-19 — just 20 days after Ramos gave birth to the couple’s last baby. In rejecting the claim, Farmers said Gaytan had a history of a heart attack and that a post-death investigation showed he had failed to disclose the medical condition on his application.
The jury factored in emotional distress and financial hardship when determining an amount, Pesek said. The family owns two La Michoacana diners that feature frozen treats. Ramos’ mother had to move in to help; an 18-year-old son set his plans aside to work at the business. The family’s truck was repossessed. She fell behind on vendor bills, impacting their business reputation. They borrowed money.
Pesek acknowledged the state Insurance Department probably cannot get Ramos paid, saying that fight is likely headed to the Nebraska Supreme Court. But he said the department can offer lawmakers a sense of whether Nebraskans in other Farmers cases might have been improperly denied benefits.
He asked the department to use its authority to examine Farmers’ personnel training, policy forms and other records to shed light on denied claims and practices. If violations are revealed, the complaint asks that the department determine corrective action.
“People go to jail for stealing $100 from a cash register,” Pesek said. “Farmers has been allowed to steal $350,000 from a Nebraska family without any consequence for six years.”
Pesek said he has spoken to at least one state lawmaker and will push to have the Legislature take up changes in the coming session, including allowing punitive damages in bad-faith cases, with the money going to the state’s public school fund; making pre-judgment interest automatic in bad-faith claims; and allowing attorneys’ fees on the full bad-faith award, not just the contract amount.
