Credit: Lionsgate

As one of the few badge-wearing, flag-waving, rah-rah advocates for the fourth Matrix movie, I adored The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. The book. Not the movie. The movie is the worst kind of mediocre.

Film reviews that agonize over divergences from text to screen suck. Movies and books should be judged as wholly independent entities. I am only bringing up the source material here as proof of concept. The adaptation is maddening, in that it preserves virtually everything that happens and yet loses its core essence. In doing so, it achieves something more like the antithesis of the novel’s purpose.

Like The Matrix Resurrections, the purpose of Sunrise (the book) was author Suzanne Collins repeating herself in a raised voice to address misreadings of The Hunger Games series. To be fair, like untangling an ouroboros, it is easy to lose the moral fiber of a fictional series that condemns authoritarian capitalistic abuses but was turned into a multibillion-dollar blockbuster major studio franchise released during America’s second Gilded Age. “The cruelty is the point” is the point, and Sunrise (the movie) ever-so-slightly sanding down the edges for a PG-13 rating negates the very reason for its existence.

As it currently exists, the new film is typical prequel stuff: It is all redundancies and context. Set 24 years before our first trip to Panem, Sunrise (both versions) details the 50th Hunger Games. That is when Haymitch (Joseph Zada) became the last living kid among the 48 (or so) forced to fight for the death in an only-barely-more-dystopian America. Haymitch loves his girlfriend, Lenore (Whitney Peak). That is about all we are shown about him before a series of unfortunate events leads him to get reaped on his birthday to enter the games.

From there, it is essentially a parade of younger actors playing familiar characters and uniformly doing a fantastic job of that. Specifically, each evokes the voice of their elder counterpart from previous films to a haunting degree. That said, the games themselves consist of the PG-13 “We didn’t steal this from Batal Royale, I swear” child-on-child violence that we’ve come to expect. We already know who wins here. We already know that the attempt to “break the machine” and score a victory for the rebellion fails.

Here’s where it gets tricky. Haymitch suffers mightily. Children die horrifically. President Snow (Ralph Fiennes) and his enablers are grotesque. But the tone is off. Just ever-so-slightly. For its purpose, nothing is shocking enough. The moments of anguish and sobriety are too quick, something that’s hard to achieve in a movie that’s closer to three hours than two.

Let’s set aside the book entirely. The adaptation of Sunrise could (and should) have been a rejoinder to the mass popularity and franchise-ification of the film series. In a promo I saw for the movie, one of the stars direct-to-camera excitedly spoke about how there were more tributes than ever in these games. That wasn’t a wink-wink bit of meta commentary. In an ad for the movie, they were repeating a talking point used by the villains about the games from the books/movies.

It is not that Sunrise (the movie) isn’t gross enough. It’s not that it changed, skipped, or omitted key deaths or events. They’re all there. Director Francis Lawrence and screenwriters Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie preserved pretty much everything. But the tone is wrong. The (ahem) execution is wrong. Not by a lot, just by a little. But missing by a millimeter here means that it accidentally reinforces the most incorrect thing. It is a movie promoted using the literal same selling points as the evildoers hyping the games.

Setting aside all of that, it’s largely fine. Zada is charismatic and nails Woody Harrelson’s voice, glossing over any problems invited by hairlines and wigs. Like the previous prequel flick, The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, it feels as though the cinematographer was a Smurf. Everything is shot from angles so low that it does become less of a stylistic decision and more madness inducing. The CGI is passable. The set pieces are ho-hum. It’s fine.

If I hadn’t read Sunrise, every criticism would be the same. I only know from having it read it what the intention was. Without it, I understand the criticisms of its banal exploitation that others have leveraged against the series from the beginning. I think it is still an important and potentially vital fictional world, just not this time out.

Grade = C

Other Critical Voices to Consider

Siddhant Adlakha at Video Game Town says “It’s a film of great suffering in service of a greater good, and a tale that may have verged on emotionally pornographic were it an isolated story. As connective tissue between various parts of the Hunger Games saga, it fits in snugly enough, making for a fitting “lost chapter” in a much larger story about carving out better tomorrows.”

Amy Nicholson at the LA Times says “The full arc of Haymitch’s hope, disillusionment and despair doesn’t land with any impact until the film’s strong final minutes. Several plot points are muddled as is the sound design, particularly in a scene where two characters shout teary, unintelligible promises at each other. Even the bird symbolism has gotten sloppy.”

DarkSkyLady says “Many of the deaths in here feel lackluster because there is either no blood or they literally become drowned in special effects. Sadly, the earlier films were still able to make the deaths have weight while The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping struggles in that department.”